@DSRIGGS You and I have the opposite perspective on psychiatrists. When I was first diagnosed with cancer and thought I was going to have to say goodbye to my kids and then my 20 year old pet passed away while I was travelling for medical evalation, I experienced real depression for the first time in my life and Zoloft was the only thing that made it bearable enough for me to function. I've also seen amazing results of psych meds with a former schoolmate who developed schizophrenia and know that while there isn't a perfect solution, for those friends who suffer from bipolar disorder, meds are usually better than no meds.
I watched my Mom suffer with depression/bipolar'sm for years. The truth is that psychiatrists didn't know for sure what the diagnosis was because there isn't really any objective test that says with 100% certainty that, yep "this is a fracture of the femur". It is "feel" based off of talking to the patient for a few minute. My was on a bazillion different meds that sometimes made her less of a zombie and sometimes made her worse.
Cameron was diagnosed Bipolar by one guy and given a drug for that and is caused a suicide/self harm attempt. The psychiatrist at the hospital said he was not Bipolar but had anxiety and depression and he went on the meds the other guy prescribed and on to new meds. None of the meds helped his depression and mood one bit, but they all made him like a zombie and he could barely function. The only thing that ever did anything remotely effective for relief of his symptoms was ECT and the anesthesiologist used Ketamine to put him out. He felt better for a week or two and then right back to the same. You can't do ECT forever, and it was Cameron's belief that the Ketamine is what made him feel better. There are ongoing trials that do ketamine therapy over a couple months and it is reported to have good success. Of course he wasn't able to get into any of the trials because he had self harmed. There is a guy in Chicagoland who combines Ketamine therapy and transcranial magnetic stimulation. The claims to have wonderful results. When I called to ask about pricing and insurance I got a call back later from a former patient who was selling me on the wonders of the treatment (felt like snake oil being pushed at us). There office doesn't even submit to insurance and the guy wanted some ridiculous amount of money like $2,500 per treatment and of course said that Cameron would need 20 treatments initially and then maintenance every 6-12 months. $75K of treatments for 3 days a week for 6 weeks , and then you have to come back every so often (got the hook in deep so reel em in) was just not doable.
I am glad that Zoloft works for you and for others. Meds can be and are effective for some of the population. Like I said my Mom would do okay for 18-36 months and then she would turn in to an almost vegitative state (my Mom was a passionate and outspoken Nurse who loved helping others so it was heartbreaking to see her like that). The Pschiatrist would then run her through umpteen other drugs until they found something that worked for a while, but it always ended in her back in the same sad place.
My experience with psychiatrists, and Cameron has seen probably 5 different ones is that they want to do nothing but prescribe meds and do zero one on one counseling. I think it is ludicrous that they do zero actual behavioral work with their patients and pawn that off onto a psychologist. To me it is like if your HVAC system at home went out and the guy came out to replace your system. He takes the old one out and puts the new one in but won't hook it up to power because he isn't an electrician so he can't do that part of the job. You have to call an electrician if you want your new $15K system furnace and AC to actually, you know, work! You paid for a new functioning system, not just half of the job.
I have great respect for what therapists do, and try to do for patients. I don't have that same respect for the Psychiatry industry because I don't see that they do anything but throw darts at the wall with meds that take 1-2 months to even start to work, and often do more harm than good. Dr K always says that we need to follow the Science and I don't see these guys/gals doing that.
JMO and whatever works for the individual that individual needs to do. I just see our mental health system as lacking and if somebody has relatively treatable depression the PCP can prescribe and manage those meds, unless the patient doesn't respond. IMO they PCP has a better understanding of the patient than the Psychiatrist and the PCP also knows how these things interact with other drugs.
Again, JMO.
BTW, schizophrenia is one of the mental health disorders that is objectively diagnosed and effective medications exist. I have a cousin who suffers from that and when he stays on his meds he can function, when he choose not to, watch out.