Susan in Tennessee
Well-Known Member
Are you saying Dr. Ayoola is suggesting you have the Sips? Not sure what you were meaning, and wanted to clarify. That’s all.
Confused what I should do!? DS or Loop
- Thread starter Gigindallas
- Start date
-
- Tags
- alibhai duodenal switch loop matin sadi
Help Support Bariatric & Weight Loss Surgery Forum:
Gigindallas
Member
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2018
- Messages
- 21
At one point Yes.. I was going to be his first SIPS patient, but days before the surgery we both foundout that insurance wouldn’t cover it... so he did my sleeve instead.
Larra
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2013
- Messages
- 3,558
Well, I haven't been at this quite as long as DianaCox, but over 12 years is still a significant time. I don't have a backpack and don't know, or know of anyone else, carrying around gobs of vitamins in one. I do know a lot of very happy people who last weight successfully, and have kept it off without strict dieting. Not that we don't have to pay attention to what we eat, but it's a whole different way of life, and a much better one. I will gladly take a few more pills every day for that.
What the best long term studies have shown is that the rate of nutritional deficiencies with the DS is remarkably low, AND when it does happen it's almost always due to noncompliance. And that's what I've seen on message boards as well - the people who complain a few years out about their health maladies were not complaint, or got terrible advice to start with, didn't get and/or follow the necessary labs, etc. The people who do play by the DS rules do very well.
What I have also seen is that some people do well with SIPS (or whatever you want to call it) and some do poorly. Some of the ones who do poorly were misled into thinking they were getting a traditional 2 anastomosis DS, find out only later, when it's not working so well, that they got a SIPS, and are very upset/ frustrated/distraught/angry.
But you're gonna do what you're gonna do, and I hope it does work out for you, but don't be surprised when you find yourself continuing to diet to sustain whatever weight loss you achieve.
What the best long term studies have shown is that the rate of nutritional deficiencies with the DS is remarkably low, AND when it does happen it's almost always due to noncompliance. And that's what I've seen on message boards as well - the people who complain a few years out about their health maladies were not complaint, or got terrible advice to start with, didn't get and/or follow the necessary labs, etc. The people who do play by the DS rules do very well.
What I have also seen is that some people do well with SIPS (or whatever you want to call it) and some do poorly. Some of the ones who do poorly were misled into thinking they were getting a traditional 2 anastomosis DS, find out only later, when it's not working so well, that they got a SIPS, and are very upset/ frustrated/distraught/angry.
But you're gonna do what you're gonna do, and I hope it does work out for you, but don't be surprised when you find yourself continuing to diet to sustain whatever weight loss you achieve.
I don’t appreciate untruths being spread. And there is no long term evidence, and there IS evidence that fat malabsorption goes away after the first year. Fat malabsorption is what keeps DSers weight off off long term. And the number of people who need reversion/reversal for too much malabsorption is vanishingly small - about 0.7%. See Marceau et al. Most of the issues people run into are non-compliance, alcohol abuse, and incompetently performed surgeries (limb lengths inappropriate for that person).
